$14,250,000
Edgartown, MA 02539
MLS# 22601953
6 beds | 6 baths
1 / 1
Property Description
This expansive historic compound in the heart of Edgartown village seamlessly blends old-world charm with modern luxury. Just steps from top restaurants and shops, the property has been meticulously renovated by Stern McCafferty Architecture + Interiors, balancing contemporary design with classic architectural detail. Inside, open-plan living spaces are designed for effortless entertaining, with sleek furnishings flowing from the kitchen and dining area through French doors to a beautifully landscaped patio--perfect for al fresco dining. Beyond, a lush lawn and manicured gardens frame a stunning 42' x 18' pool, creating a private outdoor oasis. The second level features four spacious bedrooms, including a refined primary suite with office, ensuite bath, and private deck overlooking the pool. The third floor offers a generous sleeping area with six twin beds, full bath, game space, and sunlit deck access. Located on North Water Street, this light-filled home presents a rare opportunity to own a truly exceptional retreat.
Details
Maps
Documents
Legal and Taxes
Town: Edgartown
Village: Edgartown
Estimated Annual Taxes: 22841
Building Assessments: 6177200
Other Assessments: 0
Total Assessment: 9210153
Title Reference - Book: 0085
Title Reference - Page: 0037
Flood Ins Required: No
Lead Base Paint: No
Mass Use Code: 109 - Residential, multiple houses
Street #: 68
Pre Direction: N
Street Name: Water
Street Suffix: Street
County: Dukes
State: MA
Zip Code: 02539
Tax ID: EDGA M:020D B:0234 L:
Tax Year: 2026
General Property Info
Region: Dukes County
School District: Martha's Vineyard
Zoning: R5
Property Sub-Type: Single Family Residence
Renovated: Yes
Year Renovated: 2024
Stories: 3
Total Rooms: 16
Field Card SqFt: 0
Basement: Yes
Baths - Half: 1
Association: No
Private Dock: No
Private Pool: Yes
Lot Size SqFt: 13350
Leased Land: No
Lot Size Source: Assessor
Acres: 0.31
Garage: Yes
# of Cars: 2
# of Parking Spaces: 5
Year Round: Yes
Separate Living Qtrs: Yes
Golf Course Front: No
Golf Course View: No
Waterfront: No
Waterview: Yes
Water Body View: Edgartown Harbor
Waterview Type: Bay/Harbor
Miles to Beach: .1 - .3
Fireplace: Yes
# Fireplaces: 7
Property Includes Recording Devices: No
Year Built: 1880
Bedrooms - Total: 6
Baths - Full: 5
Baths - Total: 6
Remarks & Misc
Public Remarks: This expansive historic compound in the heart of Edgartown village seamlessly blends old-world charm with modern luxury. Just steps from top restaurants and shops, the property has been meticulously renovated by Stern McCafferty Architecture + Interiors, balancing contemporary design with classic architectural detail. Inside, open-plan living spaces are designed for effortless entertaining, with sleek furnishings flowing from the kitchen and dining area through French doors to a beautifully landscaped patio--perfect for al fresco dining. Beyond, a lush lawn and manicured gardens frame a stunning 42' x 18' pool, creating a private outdoor oasis. The second level features four spacious bedrooms, including a refined primary suite with office, ensuite bath, and private deck overlooking the pool. The third floor offers a generous sleeping area with six twin beds, full bath, game space, and sunlit deck access. Located on North Water Street, this light-filled home presents a rare opportunity to own a truly exceptional retreat.
Directions to Property: Halfway down North Water Street on the left side
Street Description
Paved: 1
Public: 1
Special Listing Cond
None: 1
Lot Features
Fenced/Enclosed: 1
Gentle Sloping: 1
Year Built Desc
Actual: 1
Cer. Historic: 1
Basement Description
Other - See Remarks: 1
Parking Features
Driveway: 1
Off Street: 1
Architectural Style
Colonial: 1
Garage Description
Detached: 1
Sep Living Qtrs Info
Baths - Full: 1
Beds: 1
Baths - Total: 1
Neighborhood Amen
Beach Access: 1
Conservation Area: 1
Golf Course: 1
Rubbish Removal: 1
Foundation Details
Poured: 1
Convenient To
Bike Path: 1
Conservation Area: 1
In Town Location: 1
Marina: 1
Shopping: 1
Convenient to Water Body 1: Edgartown Harbor
Floors
Hardwood: 1
Tile: 1
Sewer
Public Sewer: 1
Separate Living Qtrs
Detached: 1
Fencing
Fenced: 1
Roof Description
Asphalt: 1
Siding Description
Clapboard: 1
Primary Bedroom
Primary Bedroom: 1
Primary Bedroom Level: Second Floor
Balcony: 1
Fireplace: Wood Burning
Flooring: Wood
Office/Sitting Area: 1
Private Full Bath: 1
Walk-in Closet: 1
Heating
Forced Air: 1
Bedroom 2
Bedroom 2: 1
Bedroom 2 Level: Second Floor
Fireplace: Wood Burning
Flooring: Wood
Private Full Bath: 1
Recessed Lighting: 1
Cooling
Central Air: 1
Bedroom 3
Bedroom 3: 1
Bedroom 3 Level: Second Floor
Fireplace: Wood Burning
Flooring: Wood
Recessed Lighting: 1
Shared Full Bath: 1
Fuel Type
Propane: 1
Bedroom 4
Bedroom 4: 1
Bedroom 4 Level: Second Floor
Fireplace: Wood Burning
Flooring: Wood
Shared Full Bath: 1
Water
Public: 1
Hot Water
Water Heater: 1
Hot Water Source
Propane Gas: 1
Laundry Room
Laundry Room: 1
Living/Dining Combo
No: 1
Living Room
Living Room: 1
Living Room Level: First Floor
Fireplace: Wood Burning
Recessed Lighting: 1
Dining Room
Dining Room: 1
Dining Room Level: First Floor
Fireplace: Wood Burning
Flooring: Wood
Kitchen/Dining Combo
No: 1
Kitchen
Pantry: 1
Kitchen: 1
Kitchen Level: First Floor
Flooring: Wood
Kitchen Island: 1
Stove: Gas
Other Structures
Pool House: 1
Other Room 1
Room Type: Bedroom 5
Level: Third Floor
Exterior Features
Garden: 1
Outdoor Shower: 1
Private Yard: 1
Underground Sprinkler System: 1
Other Room 2
Room Type: Den
Level: First Floor
Other Room 3
Room Type: Home Office
Level: Second Floor
Appliances
Dishwasher: 1
Freezer: 1
Gas Range: 1
Refrigerator: 1
Washer: 1
Wine Cooler: 1
Interior Features
Recessed Lighting: 1
Walk-In Closet(s): 1
Wet Bar: 1
Private Pool Description
Gunite: 1
Heated: 1
In Ground: 1
DPR Eligibility
DPR Eligible: No
Contract Info
Status: Active
Original List Price: 14250000
List Price: $14,250,000
Current Price: $14,250,000
List Date: 2026-05-05
Property Features
Street Description: Paved; Public
Special Listing Cond: None
Architectural Style: Colonial
Year Built Desc: Actual; Cer. Historic
Basement Description: Other - See Remarks
Foundation Details: Poured
Lot Features: Fenced/Enclosed; Gentle Sloping
Neighborhood Amen: Beach Access; Conservation Area; Golf Course; Rubbish Removal
Garage Description: Detached
Parking Features: Driveway; Off Street
Separate Living Qtrs: Detached
Convenient To: Bike Path; Conservation Area; In Town Location; Marina; Shopping
Primary Bedroom: Primary Bedroom; Balcony; Office/Sitting Area; Private Full Bath; Walk-in Closet
Bedroom 2: Bedroom 2; Private Full Bath; Recessed Lighting
Bedroom 3: Bedroom 3; Recessed Lighting; Shared Full Bath
Bedroom 4: Bedroom 4; Shared Full Bath
Laundry Room: Laundry Room
Living Room: Living Room; Recessed Lighting
Dining Room: Dining Room
Kitchen: Kitchen; Kitchen Island; Pantry
Appliances: Dishwasher; Freezer; Gas Range; Refrigerator; Washer; Wine Cooler
Floors: Hardwood; Tile
Interior Features: Recessed Lighting; Walk-In Closet(s); Wet Bar
Private Pool Description: Gunite; Heated; In Ground
Other Structures: Pool House
Exterior Features: Garden; Outdoor Shower; Private Yard; Underground Sprinkler System
Fencing: Fenced
Roof Description: Asphalt
Siding Description: Clapboard
Sewer: Public Sewer
Heating: Forced Air
Cooling: Central Air
Fuel Type: Propane
Water: Public
Hot Water: Water Heater
Hot Water Source: Propane Gas
Home Inspection Disclosure 
Listing Office: Wallace & Co. Sotheby's International Realty
Listing Agent: Tom C Wallace
Last Updated: May - 14 - 2026
All data relating to real estate for sale on this page comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the Cape Cod & Islands Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Detailed information about real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than CC&I Assoc. of REALTORS, Inc include the name of the listing company. Neither the listing company nor CC&I Assoc. of REALTORS, Inc shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. The Broker providing this data believes it to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm any item before relying on it in a purchase decision. This site was last updated 02/14/2017. All properties are subject to prior sale, changes, or withdrawal. Copyright 2020© Cape Cod & Islands Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved